Professional Review:
When You Reach Me
Rebecca Stead. 2009. New York: Wendy Lamb.
The year is 1979 and 12-year-old Miranda is facing a lot of chal-
lenges in life. She is trying to help her mother prepare to compete
and win on
The $20,000 Pyramid
television show by practicing
The $20,000 Pyramid
television show by practicing
The $20,000 Pyramid
with her every night, learning to navigate sixth-grade society, at-
tempting to determine the qualities of true friendship, and struggling with a
bizarre secret that defies explanation.
When her best friend for life (she thought), Sal, seems to abandon her,
Miranda is not only hurt but also frustrated by his strange behavior. A compli-
cated chain of events begins when an older boy punches Sal as he and Miranda
make their way home and ends as the story accelerates to its close. People are not
always who they appear to be, and events that seem completely unrelated may
have everything to do with each other when a final karmic event restores justice
in Miranda’s world.
Miranda’s favorite novel is Madeleine L’Engle’s
A Wrinkle in Time
, a story of
travel and conflict across time and dimensions. Elements of L’Engle’s story work
their way into Miranda’s own conflicts with an eccentric homeless man who in-
habits her block on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, with other young women her
age, with Sal, and with an anonymous stranger whom Miranda never sees but
who manages to leave her notes that accurately predict events before they happen
to her. The stranger claims to have come to save the life of someone Miranda
cares about and seems to know much more about her than anyone possibly could.
His only request is that she write him a letter about how the events of her life
turn out, and this letter becomes the book’s narration premise.
All will be explained in the end, but in the meantime, Miranda will help her
mother become a successful competitor on
The $20,000 Pyramid
, work for free
at Jimmy’s Sandwich Shop, come to terms with differences of race and socioeco-
nomic status, explore the possibility of a stepfather, and figure out who her real
friends are. Only at the very end will she learn what happened with Sal, why the
homeless man spends so much time under the mailbox, who is leaving her the
notes, and what all of this has to do with her life.
Rebecca Stead brilliantly weaves details of setting from memories of her
own teen years on the Upper West Side, including a strange individual and her
mom’s appearance with Dick Clark on
The $20,000 Pyramid
. The story’s science
fiction aspect will not become readily apparent until almost the very end, but it
is crucial to the plot (Blasingame, 2011).
Reference: Blasingame, J. (March, 2011). When you reach me. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy. 54(6) p461-464
- Library Uses: When You Reach Me could be used to have students discuss and write about the mysterious. Students can research the topic of time travel.